GPT-4 Prompt Engineering: The “Rate This” Prompt

I’ve always been intrigued by the potential of artificial intelligence in our daily lives. Recently, I stumbled upon a fascinating GPT-4 prompt that not only evaluates your ideas but also provides constructive feedback and suggests improvements. Intrigued? 

So was I! In this article, I’ll take you on a journey through my experience with the GPT-4 “Rate This” prompt, sharing insights on how it works, and showcasing examples of how it can help refine your ideas.

Read more or watch the YouTube video(Recommended)


What is the GPT-4 “Rate This” Prompt?

When I created the GPT-4 “Rate This” prompt I designed it to evaluate a user’s ideas or problems, assigning them a rating from zero to five stars based on their merit. What truly fascinates me is that it doesn’t stop at simply providing a rating. GPT-4 goes the extra mile by offering constructive feedback and even suggesting improvements to enhance the user’s idea, potentially turning a two-star concept into a five-star one.

During my exploration, I’ve found that this prompt leverages GPT-4’s extensive knowledge and expertise across various fields, such as business, creativity, and logic, to provide thoughtful and insightful feedback.

As a user, you can input your ideas, whether they’re related to investment, negotiations, or even the inception of a YouTube channel, and GPT-4 will offer a well-rounded assessment based on a five-star rating system.

The GPT-4 also presents a detailed explanation of the rating, touching upon all the relevant aspects that contribute to the idea’s success or failure.

I’m genuinely impressed by the GPT-4 “Rate This” prompt and its potential to guide users in refining their ideas for better outcomes.


How can you use the GPT-4 “Rate This” Prompt?

The GPT-4 “Rate This” prompt is an incredibly useful prompt engineering tool that can help you evaluate and improve ideas, messages, or projects by leveraging the power of AI. To use this prompt, you need to provide your idea or text input to the AI model and request it to rate your work on a five-star scale.

GPT-4 will assess your input based on various criteria, such as clarity, innovation, and effectiveness, and provide you with a numerical rating alongside a well-reasoned explanation of its assessment.

In order to make the most out of the GPT-4 “Rate This” prompt, it’s important to provide clear and concise context to your input. Start by outlining your idea, message, or project in a straightforward manner, and then ask GPT-4 to rate it based on the established criteria.

Once you receive your rating and feedback, you can use that information to refine your work, addressing any weak points or areas for improvement. If you’re still not satisfied with your rating, you can request GPT-4  to transform your idea into a higher-rated one, providing you with invaluable insights and creative suggestions that can take your work to the next level.

Examples of the GPT-4 “Rate This” Prompt

Here are a few examples of what the GPT-4 “Rate This” Prompt can do:

Example 1: Rate This Business Idea

User: I have a business idea where I want to create an online marketplace for people to buy and sell second-hand electronics. The platform will verify the quality and functionality of each item before it is listed, ensuring that customers receive reliable products at a lower cost than new items. The website will also offer a recycling program for users to dispose of their old electronics responsibly. Can you please rate this business idea?

GPT-4: I rate this business idea 4.5 out of 5 stars. The concept of an online marketplace for verified second-hand electronics is innovative and addresses a market need for affordable and reliable electronic products. Additionally, the recycling program promotes sustainability and responsible disposal of electronic waste. To further improve the idea, consider offering a warranty or a return policy for customers and focusing on user-friendly interface and customer support.


Example 2 : Rate This Business Idea

User: I have a business idea where I want to open a store that sells only ice cream made from highly unconventional and potentially unappetizing ingredients, such as garlic, raw fish, and hot sauce. The store would not offer any traditional or popular ice cream flavors, and the main focus would be on creating the most bizarre ice cream combinations possible. Can you please rate this business idea?

GPT-4: I rate this business idea 1.5 out of 5 stars. While the concept of offering unique and unconventional ice cream flavors demonstrates creativity, it is likely to have limited appeal and market demand due to the unappetizing nature of the proposed ingredients. The absence of traditional or popular flavors further limits the potential customer base. To improve the idea, consider offering a mix of both unconventional and popular flavors, and focus on creating novelty ice cream combinations that are still enjoyable to a wider audience.


In conclusion, my experience with the GPT-4 “Rate This” prompt has been nothing short of fascinating. Not only has it allowed me to explore the potential of large language models in evaluating and refining ideas, but it has also shown me how powerful and insightful a great GPT-4 prompt can be when it comes to providing constructive feedback.

Whether you’re looking for guidance on your business ideas, improving your negotiation skills, or simply wanting a second opinion on your creative projects, the GPT-4 “Rate This” prompt can be an invaluable tool in your pursuit of success.

So, go ahead, give it a try, and witness the power of GPT-4 in transforming your ideas into their best possible versions.


  1. Good day Kris. My name is Dmitry I have a small business with my wife, we actually produce women clothes, and we are up already for 15 years. So we have this big part of our workflow – the fashion/catalog photo shooting. Over the years as our business got bigger we had less time for some “creative” work. For example shooting in an open world rater then in the studio. Because you know it takes time to get every body organized. But now we just shoot in the studio. So I have been following the trend of AI, and been feeling that the answer for commercial fashion photography is some where close. Unfortunately my English does not let me use midjourney and chat gpt for a 100%. So after viewing all your videos I have come up with an idea of sponsoring a video guide called “the use of ai in commercial photography”. I would give you the raw photos and try to explain what it would be great to obtain with the ai.

  2. Hi Kris. Could you teach me something about the use of symbols in chatting? I mean {}, [], *, etc.
    For example:
    Reverse Prompt Engineer the following {text}…

  3. Thanks for all the great work you ore doing. Strange I tried to ask Midjourney about a biz idea- even put your same Q above but it would not rate the idea. Even tried GPT 4. Mabe you gave it a different prompt.

  4. Hi, if you could, please send me also information about using symbols,expressions, or scripting when chatting GPT,
    Thank you in advance

  5. Hi Kristian,
    Would it be possible for you to help me get the Prompt engineering techniques for video content creation and for running email marketing campaign.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *